Alam Zeb Safi [The News]
KARACHI: Former captain Mohammad Essa has said if the foreign-based footballers are unable to join the camp at least 20 to 25 days ahead of any international event then they should not be inducted into the squad as their late arrival always harms the national team.
“I am not against these players because they are good both physically and technically. But there is a great difference in the playing style of these boys and our players and when they join the team’s camp late the team faces great problems in coordination while playing in international events,” Essa told ‘The News’ in an interview on Thursday.
“They should either be brought into the team’s preparatory camp 20 or 25 days before the start of any international event or should not be considered at all as our home-based boys are also capable to perform,” the Chaman-born playmaker said.
Essa said that Pakistan have always suffered losses since these players have been playing in the team.
“Tell me where we have performed with these players. The main problem with them is that being professional players and most loyal to their clubs they normally don’t play with the type of courage and commitment our own boys play with while representing Pakistan in international competitions. They try to protect themselves from injuries. And if a player does not offer his hundred percent it normally affects the performance of the whole team,” stressed the 27-year old player, who retired in 2009.
Four ‘foreign’ players including England-based Zeeshan Rehman, Atif Bashir, Adnan Farooq Ahmed and Ahmed Akber Khan from Australia were part of the team which lost to Bangladesh 0-3 in Dhaka on Wednesday in their first leg of the opening round of the World Cup 2014 qualifiers.
Both the teams will face each other in the second leg at the Punjab Stadium in Lahore on July 3.
Midfielder Adnan Farooq Ahmed (Aboomoslem FC, Iran) and defender Atif Bashir (Barry Town, Wales) had joined the team’s camp for the qualifiers in Islamabad barely four or five days before the team’s departure to Dhaka on June 27 while defender Zeeshan Rehman, who plays for Muangthong United FC in the Thailand top league, joined the team in the Bangladeshi capital just a day before Pakistan’s key first leg of the qualifiers. However, striker Ahmed Akber Khan, who does not have any professional commitment in Australia, was in the camp right from the start.
About Pakistan’s miserable loss at the hands of Bangladesh in the first leg of the qualifiers, Essa said Bangladesh are a better team but three goals are too much.
“I believe that Bangladesh is a better side but the 0-3 defeat is too much. They win against Pakistan because they have better domestic structure than what we have here in our own country. Their club level coaching is of good standard. Their clubs not only have some foreign coaches but have also roped in foreign players as well. Their league also spans over six months which keeps the players fit for national duty,” he said.
Under Essa’s captaincy, Pakistan had held Bangladesh to a goalless draw in their SAFF Championship match in Dhaka in 2009.
He said that the constant disruption of the team’s combination and coach has always harmed Pakistan team.
“There is a general trend here that when a team starts settling down and produces results, its combination is broken by ignoring majority of the players. The current team playing in the qualifiers comprises of the best available talent and I must advise the authorities to stick with it and in a couple of years you will see a marked improvement in their performance,” he said.
“Similarly the PFF should stick to a single coach and give him at least three years. Better results cannot be produced overnight and particularly when our domestic structure needs lot of improvement,” Essa concluded.





I actually agree with Essa to an extent. The foreign players should come earlier to camp. Not 20 days early, as Essa proposes, but at least one week prior to the match is good.
However, the biggest problem is the coaching. With a decent foreign coach for two years, we can easily dominate South Asia and be well respected in Asia, even with a completely domestic squad.
And those foreigners who do join the camp early (Yousuf Butt and Irfan Khan) and mistreated by incompetent coaching staff are then accused of ‘lack of commitment’ and asked to leave!
Essa talking bull again. He was the one who was disrupting team morale and stability in 2009 SAFF Cup for throwing tantrums like a kid because Kottan wanted to utilise him better by playing him in midfield because of his own severe lack of pace! Joining a pointless and mediocre ‘training camp’ where nothing real is done 20-25 days before a game is a ridiculous demand. Essa should just focus on being a glorious has-been and focus on KESC!
I dont understand why is it always the ‘foreigners’ to blame? The track record of Atif, Adnan, and even Zesh in recent games has been much better than our local sarkari mulazims! Atif and Adnan have consistently been our best players.
Maybe Zesh’s mentality and conduct in unnecessary panicking over his club career in missing vital games and reporting to team just before the game is the only legit concern as he is too distracted to be playing in the team consistently! But Adnan and Atif have been the best we have.
y not we devople their standard which foriegn player play.
Essa has a point, the players need to be playing together in order to perform as a team. Its not about individuals.
Having said that these players have skills and experience the locals lack. What I dont understand is that the only foreign player that has been in the training camp from the start gets 5mins on the park.
Our domestic structure is pretty horrible as well
i agreed with essa
Essa should come out of retirement if he cares about Pakistani Football so much!
Essa you should sulk in retirement with your stupid demand of being captain!
I AGREE that foreigne players must come at training camp not four or fuve days but atleast 10 days in advance because to get use to each other ball passing etc. this is a golden rule here in the west in europe !!!! when international matches come for a major tournaments if players cant come earlier they are sacked away !!!! because is the difrent between winning and loosing but on the other hand i have learned that bagladesh prepared mutch later for this mutch with no coach or a new one just in technically they had an horible preperation but they score 3 times i think it is the rain to blame in lahore i you want to win we nee agrasive strikers and good midfield and hopefully they wil play more atacking and defendders wil stay awake and not sleepin hopefully they wil stick wit their man defending !!!!
this guy has gone nuts…atleast those players are showing up for the damned team…what the hell is Essa kha doin…come out of your damned retirement and starrt playing else shut up
Foreign based players are playing at a higher level with the inclusion also of being coached by a higher qualified and experienced coach. To turn up almost a month in advance is not happening as the structure of football in more superior footballing nations doesnt give you that lengthy time off (even in semi-professional clubs). Secondly, to have such players who HAVE been coached with quality coaches will most certainly not enjoy being coached at a much lower coaching ability amongst players with lower technical ability and understanding of the game. It is only my humble opinion, but players who compete at a higher level, and are coached at a higher level can add to football, an good ingredient to the structure on the pitch. I have coached Adnan Ahmed and Atif Bashir, as well as Amjad Iqbal (injured) in the UK and as a UEFA B licenced qualified coach working at Notts County FC, I can honestly say that these players will give nothing less than committment, passion and dedication to the Pakistan National football team. Adnan has played for Ferencvaros, and as for Zesh Rehman, he has played at Fulham, QPR, Bradford City and now plays in Thailand. These teams are not sub-standard to say the least. The infrastructure is second to none and players are supported with many aspects of the game. I respect Mr Essa’s comments, but sincerely do not agree with them. Having watched highlights of such recent games, I have made my own analysis and judgment as a coach. Its a shame that the foreign based players are taking the blame for the performance and repeated defeats. Any nation will always and should always pick their most experienced and quality assured players.
Well said mate.
Agree with Rehan Mirza….
Essa should stop blaming Foreigners who are dedicating such patriotism for their Nation while living abroad & earning/living a respectable/convenient life over there. whereas they don’t need to be getting into such a mess.
All they are doing is; for their country & their fore-father’s country… I have a great respect in my heart for these guys & will always welcome them….
Talking about foreigners eeehhh.What our team got a bad coach who is even worst tactition with very bad defensive tactics cant let the team play, our local player who are feeling bad about foreign based players can not stop sulking and start playing selected upon recommendations not talent,we need new foreign coach who does not select on liking disliking basis and let the team play….. Lutfi isnt the right man!
Essa is right. Pakistan can not progress with foreign based players. They need their own home grown talent. Bangladesh defeated a foreign player heavy pakistan 3-0 with players who have never been to outside of the country except for football tours. Bangladesh have the luxury to reject foreign born players like Anwaruddin and Jama Bhuyan because they got the game going at grass root level without much effort.
Essa is right. Pakistan can not progress with foreign based players. They need their own home grown talent. Bangladesh defeated a foreign player heavy pakistan 3-0 with players who have never been to outside of the country except for football tours. Bangladesh have the luxury to reject foreign born players like Anwaruddin and Jama Bhuyan because they got the game going at grass root level without much effort.
“I believe that Bangladesh is a better side but the 0-3 defeat is too much. They win against Pakistan because they have better domestic structure than what we have here in our own country. Their club level coaching is of good standard. Their clubs not only have some foreign coaches but have also roped in foreign players as well. Their league also spans over six months which keeps the players fit for national duty,” Essa said.
Couldn’t have said better!
@ Naveed…. Agree with Essa’s conclusion of Pakistani domestic structure compared with Bangaledshi domestic structure… but i think foreigners are giving something to our locals…
U know nothing about Pakistani Football & the politics going on in here…
Ahmed Akber Khan is one of the best player in the whole squad, yet due politics and the coach, he is not getting a chance to play. He is only playing like 10 minutes. If given a chance he would definately score a goal!!
i have personally seen better players than these foreigners who have missed penalties in the past.got it.they of no use and must be changed.bd used to be at par than pak.
I get the feeling you haven’t seen the national team actually in action to even say that there are better players than Atif Bashir (man of the match awards for Pakistan in Asian Game and AFC Challenge Cup qualifiers!) and Adnan Ahmed!
granted you are talking about Adnan Ahmed’s penalty miss against Sri Lanka in 2009 SAFF Cup…but why dont you also talk about Jaffar Khan stupidly conceding a penalty to Sri Lanka earlier in the same game??
and what about the horrible penalty misses of ‘local stars’ Abdul Aziz and Abbas Ali in 2009 South Asian Games in the same match, or the Samar Ishaq penalty blunder against Maldives in 2010 Asian Games??
You want to talk about that as well?
see how yousuf butt conceded the two goals.kesc’s goalkeeper is the best and jaffer khan should be thrown out
lol Yousuf Butt was not at fault for both of those goals conceded against Malaysia!
Both goals were the fault of horrible clearance and man-marking from the defenders! yet Yousuf becomes a scapegoat because he has no ‘sarkari sifarish’ and then gets accused of ‘lack of commitment’ by clueless sarkari coaching staff!
Omer has left KESC and has joined NBP, and given his form against Malaysia in return leg and against Palestine and in AFC Challenge Cup qualifiers…he is inconsistent and very lucky!
What about coach lutfi ? As he deserve As national coach ? I don’t think he deserve and in football it’s 50% coach who decide what to do when to do . Essa is right forign player should at least 14 days join the camp .