By FPDC Editor, Gauhar Mahmood Azeem
Yousuf Butt-6.5
The debutant goal keeper did really well for the 45 minutes he was on the pitch. A flap for the opening goal shouldn’t have found the Malaysian striker, we put that on the defense though. Great delivery and great commanding presence. Taken off at half time for what looked like an injury to an already bad left leg.
AhsanUllah-6
Much better than his last outing in Pakistani colours, the young defender handled the left side of the defense well and tried to participate in attack whenever possible. A neat game.
Manzoor Ahmed-6.5
Great showing by both center-backs. The WAPDA defender stayed close to the opposing striker and let him not get a sniff/shot on goal for much of the game, the shots they did take were from long range.
Alamgir Khan-6.5
Good from the other center-back. Tried to stop everything that came his way, neither of the two goals much his fault.
Faisal Iqbal-7.5
The flying full back was one of the best players for Pakistan today. Malaysia never really got the opportunity to attack from their left wing and the short yet speedy Faisal participated in attack whenever possible, even having a 40 yard cracker that sailed just over the bar.
Muhammad Adil-5
His clearance led to Malaysia volleying in their second goal. Good defending, not much attacking. Only getting a 5 because he helped Pakistan get a 2nd half clean sheet by playing his heart out in the second period.
Ansar Abbass-2.5
Oh what were you thinking? Did nothing noteworthy for the 44 minutes he was on the pitch apart from lashing out and kicking the opponent GK. At 1-0 with Pakistan dominating, his moment of madness cost us dear. The deflation after his sending off led to us conceding one more and then went the game to bed.
Touseef-6
Decent, fought really well, moved the ball around, gave his all. Nothing truly spectacular though.
Jadeed Khan-5
The captain couldn’t really recreate his Afghan FC magic at this stage, tried to find Kaleem and Rizwan with some balls but ended up playing a few long. Hit badly on his ankle in the first half, taken off just after the hour mark for Sadaam Hussien.
Rizwan Ahmed-6.5
Looked dangerous, the only one retaining the ball well high up field. Fought really hard and made some good plays. Literally played his heart out. Couldn’t get a shot on goal though as more often than not our midfield composed of 1 or 2 players really close together. Could’ve done better in a 4-1-4-1 or as withdrawn striker.
KaleemUllah-6
One shot went really close, when he missed a beautiful Volley by just a yard or two. Couldn’t get many opportunities though and most of his touches came when he dropped low to get the ball. Tired running and taken off at 80′.
Substitutes:
Muhammad Omer-8 (Man of the Match-Pakistan)
Came on at the half time interval, a strange time to come on for a GK. Produced a master-class performance to keep a 2nd half clean sheet. He might be shorter than the average goalie but his athleticism is amazing. Tipping a goal bound shot to the cross bar, handling crosses and stopping in-swinging shots. Omer, THE MAN!
Saddaam Hussien-4,5
Made no serious impact after coming on and remained anonymous. Should have passed rather than go for glory on a ball at the edge of the box.
FahadUllah-5
Got no real chance and couldn’t do much in the 10 odd minutes he got.





yeah that guy ansar should be punished….i mean what the hell….by getting red carded did not only had to go outside but also deprived the team of a player……this is criminal stuff
Re: Ansar Abbass-2.5
I agree that he should be penalized for some matches, as he did it openly and stupidly/ un-skilled.
I agree that he should be penalized for some matches, as he did it openly and stupidly/ un-skilled.
When Omer came on, I was concerned that Pakistan will be conceding far more goals, but he was very impressive. Bad luck with Yousuf as apart from those bad clearances, he dealt with the pressure rather well. Omer impressed though. Well done kid!
but he conceded 2 in one half…..whatever the performance but scoreline is what matters….if he was unfit then they should not have played him
Both goals were not his fault. Unsaveable shots.
but well done to the team for 2nd half showing…….i would have been hopeful with 1-0 result here but i think now despite home advantage would be very difficult to win on aggregate….
“even having a 40 yard cracker that sailed just over the bar”. Fiasal shot the ball?
yousuf with bad clearances? yes majid bhai, in the first half
What formation did Pak use?
I dont understand why Irfan didnt play.
agreed…………….WHY DID HE NOT PLAY???
Also Mehmood Khan, where was he today? injured?
Omer was play good. All player play ascoach was give them task . But what we can expect from lotfi.
Am real happy my keeper Omar has done real well. After winning best keeper at the SFL and best keeper in the PPL I was expecting a good performance. A great kid with a great future. Need to get him out of Pakistan into some european league.
Get him into Mid East or South-East Asian league! That will be more realistic.
I hope he impressed the scouts present. He could use some bulking up to become bigger in physique!
Hello
How R U ?
HOPE U LL FINE AND U ARE RIGHT OMER IS A GOOD GOAL KEEPER AND HE HAS GOOD TALENT AND ALSO GOOD FUTURE !
GOD GIVE HIM LOT OF SUCCESS IN FUTURE !
ZAHID TAJ
PAKISTAN YOUTH FOOTBALL COACH
NATIONAL BANK COACH
Mr. Zabe,
What is the update on your up coming football academy, is it real or just NEWS!
If you can setup a professional academy then you will be proud of whole team, which is lacking at the moment.
Thanks for the ratings, Gauhar. I was able to watch the last 25-30 minutes of the first half before leaving home, but that is not enough to form a good impression on which to write player reviews. However, I do have some observations:
The first goal, based on the highlights in the other article, was mainly Yousuf Butt’s fault. He did the same thing which Amir Gul did a couple weeks ago against Thailand. He came off his line when he didn’t need to do so. And when he came off his line, he did not make a good clearance and instead interfered with our defender who could have headed the ball out of danger. The shot by the Malaysian was very good and unstoppable, but Yousuf’s poor clearance resulted in that shot.
The second goal was not a result of Muhammad Adil’s clearance, but rather the poor clearance was made by Ahsan Ullah. Muhammad Adil, however, should not have been ball watching and instead should have been marking the Malaysian player who took the shot. Yousuf Butt was not to blame in any way for this goal, as the shot was unstoppable.
Ansar Abbas was doing OK until that utterly stupid act which he did. Very poor on his part, and he may well have cost Pakistan the chance to advance to the next round. However, I feel that the Malaysian keeper should also have been punished, as he was pushing, slapping, and kicking Ansar.
Some general observations:
I know that it is shocking to hear, but I must say that our central defence was finally solid, both defensively and offensively. They marked well and looked to pass the ball out of the back. They have to work on defending against crosses though.
The full backs defended and attacked well also, although Ahsan Ullah was looking very poor in the headers department.
The passing between defence and midfield was quite good. However, the problem was that the midfield was clueless, especially Muhammad Tauseef. The midfield would get the ball from the defence and then give a long ball to our lone striker. Totally useless. The midfield did pass the ball at times, especially Ansar Abbas and Muhammad Adil, but there was ultimately too much long ball from midfield. We have no creativity in midfield. There was sooo much space in midfield, but our guys didn’t exploit it, choosing instead to launch the ball in the air.
Also, our midfield was not supporting the attack enough. Often times one of our midfielders or the lone striker would be surrounded by 2 or 3 Malaysians and there would be no Pakistani player nearby to whom he could pass.
What can I say about the striking? There isn’t much to say when there is only a lone striker up front, and the midfield is in long ball mode.
Based on what little I saw in this match, I would rate Tariq Lutfi as being better than Akhtar Sahib but not nearly as good as George Kottan. His formation and strategy was too defensive minded, but it was well executed by the defence and strikers. The midfield was the weakest link today. However, I feel that our midfielders may have done better in a standard 4-4-2 or diamond 4-4-2 formation. His selection of Tauseef instead of Mehmood Khan is also mind boggling. Mehmood Khan would have brought some creativity to the midfield. Also, Irfan Khan should have been used as defensive mid instead of either Ansar or Adil.
One thing which was really pissing me off was that our guys were acting like Italians, especially Rizwan, Kalim, and Jadid. Even a little touch was enough to send them rolling on the ground. These guys need to grow some balls and toughen up.
I’m just disappointed I didn’t get to see Muhammad Umer in action.
Actually, here are extended highlights including many of Umer’s saves:
http://www.youtube.com/user/MrReplaytube#p/a/u/0/f2fvdJmSJ2Q
His athleticism is impressive, but he gives too many rebounds and positioning is a bit suspect. Also, he is not so commanding in the air. Good keeper, but I guess he should be kept as back up. However, I am not too impressed with Yousuf either, but Yousuf is the best choice at the moment. If only Naiman Khan had not been injured.
Do you guys think Ansar of Adil can be used at left back? Im not comfortable with Ahsanullah there, he gets beat too easily and is a liability on crosses from the little that I have seen in this game and the Asian Games.
*or
GREAt work by malik riaz PARTY FOR live COVERAGE
PAK team should be given lot of exposure to more international high class match..
Malaysian team have more experience to handle tough matches..
I think, given time.. PAK team will excell..
Btw .. love all your comment and opinion.. please no hater for both supporter…